Joel Waldfogel | Professor of Business | Wharton School | the University of Pennsylvania
Word Play
by
Samuel GreengardWhat makes Wikipedia remarkable is that you can type in almost any
word or subject in the English language and wind up with an article
displayed on your computer screen in a fraction of a second.
There's no jaunt over to the bookshelf and no shuffling through
indexes and cross-references to find a nugget of knowledge. What's
more, Wikipedia's million-plus articles in English eclipses
Britannica's 80,000,
Columbia's 51,000, and Encarta's 63,000. Even
more mind-boggling is the fact that Wikipedia adds somewhere around
2,000
entries a day.
Of course, quantity and ease of use don't necessarily equate to
quality. Some people, including Joel Waldfogel, Ehrenkranz
Professor of Business and Public Policy at the
Wharton School of
the University of
Pennsylvania, question how effectively a spirited
cadre of volunteers can produce articles compared to top
professionals and luminaries. For instance, Britannica boasts
entries from Carl Sagan, Milton Friedman, and numerous Nobel
laureates. World Book verifies any fact appearing in any article
with at least three respected sources - not including other
encyclopedias.
By comparison, Wikipedia is a virtual free-for-all, with more than
13,000 participants churning out articles. If you're inclined to
add your two cents' worth, you simply click on a tab at the top of
any entry that reads "Edit this page." You make desired changes and
click "Save page." Your words are then visible for the entire world
to see - though "page patrollers" dutifully track changes (another
tab displays the entire history of an article) and verify that the
information is appropriate and correct. They also undo vandalized
pages - usually within five minutes,
Wales says.
Related Topics:
Print this Article |