"I think people are
committing a lot of passion to Tesla, both because the car is
awesome and because the people are going about it in the
right way, a way that might actually succeed," Sexton says.
"They're marketing it first as fun and fast and sexy, and
second as electric. It competes, valuewise, with a lot of
exotic cars out there."
The idea of building a niche car to create a buzz and then moving
into mass production isn't exactly new. Siry points out that a guy
named Henry Ford made his name in the early 1900s building race
cars. In 1904, shortly after forming the Ford Motor Company, his
third attempt to create an automobile maker, he gave an exhibition
on the ice of Lake St. Clair, setting a new land speed record of
91.4 mph. Ford then sent the race car driver, Barney Oldfield,
barnstorming around the country in the new model, the 999, creating
publicity for the Ford brand.
Ford created the Detroit we know today, with its assembly lines
turning out millions of cars around the clock. But what was
efficient a century ago now comes with huge costs, Siry notes. The
big automakers face daunting structural issues, including
health-care costs, contracts with labor unions, and a production
structure that allows them to make only a high volume of cars.
"We don't have legacy issues," Siry says. "We're taking a different
approach. We're producing a low-volume car that will address a
certain niche, and then we're moving down the line to larger
volumes."
It's a model used by makers of high-tech products, everything from
computers to high-definition TVs. "In what other market do you
enter at the low end? Flat-panel TVs, cell phones, even
refrigerators were all originally pitched at the high end. That
drives the technology, creates a brand, and builds desirability in
the larger market," Eberhard told London's Financial Times. "That
seemed even more important to us with electric cars, because they
had been given such a black eye in the marketplace. People thought
about them as dorkmobiles, just ugly golf-carty things."
Eberhard has no prior experience in the car business. But then he
had no experience with electronic books before he formed NuvoMedia,
which helped create the market with its Rocket eBook. He sold the
company in 2000 for $187 million (it was later folded by the buyer,
Rupert Murdoch's Gemstar).
Eberhard met Musk, who has a net worth of $328 million and helped
create PayPal, at a Mars Society meeting (a group dedicated to the
"exploration and settlement of the Red Planet") in 2001. Three
years later, Eberhard and Tarpenning, Tesla's cofounder and vice
president of engineering, approached Musk to back Tesla Motors. "He
gave me half an hour to make a presentation, which turned into two
hours, and by the end, we had a handshake deal that he would invest
in the company," Eberhard explains. (Musk is also backing SpaceX,
the rocket-launch company that recently won a NASA contract to
develop a vehicle to service the International Space Station.)
Today, Tesla has venture capital of more than $100 million,
including the initial investment from Musk.
The company is building an assembly plant in New Mexico, but like
so many Silicon Valley ventures, it is using technologies invented
and assembled elsewhere. For example, the lithium-ion cells used
for the battery are wired together into sheets in Thailand and
surrounded by a computer system that manages charge levels and
cools the cells.
Even the company's signature technology is borrowed.
Nineteenth-century physicist Nikola Tesla built the first AC
induction motor, the same kind of motor that gives the Roadster its
silent roar. What is proprietary and what the company controls are
the 15 patent applications that focus on the power train.
The motor, which weighs only 70 pounds, sits in the rear of the
car, along with the battery. The battery is equipped with 13
processors that monitor everything from voltage and temperature to
smoke levels; these processors are linked to an onboard computer
that controls such things as the speed of the motor, braking, and
battery charging. And those cooling vents in the rear of the car
work like the vents on the back of your desktop PC tower.
"The things that are the core competency of Tesla - like the drive
train - are things we hold closely," Siry says. "The battery pack,
our power electronics, the mechanism to turn energy into motion,
and the motor are unique to Tesla. That's where the patents
are."
What Tesla will leverage are the suppliers Detroit uses, as well as
its experience. The company has opened an office in Rochester Hills
(north of Detroit). It has hired about two dozen auto-industry
veterans and employs more than 60 people in total.
"The ecosystem for auto manufacturing looks very different," Siry
says. "We have access to the same suppliers Detroit uses. We don't
have to build everything from scratch. For example, for White Star
[the code name for Tesla's next planned car], we have an assembly
plant in Albuquerque we're building. But we are not going to build
the tooling to manufacture the body. We'll have someone else do
that. They will stamp the aluminum and paint the car for us. We
don't need to invest in massive infrastructure to do these
things."
When Silicon Valley's talent for innovation merges with Detroit
veterans who understand how to make cars, "it really becomes
magical," Siry adds.
To ramp up production on future cars, Siry says, Tesla will need
access to even more capital. Some of it will come from Tesla's
selling technology it has developed. Earlier this year, the
start-up announced it had created a new division to sell
lithium-ion battery packs and had taken a $43 million order for
2007 and 2008 from Think, a Norwegian maker of tiny electric cars.
In his blog, Eberhard said the company went through seven design
iterations before producing its Energy Storage Systems.
"Along the way, word got out that Tesla Motors ESS technology is
pretty darned good. Unsolicited, cell manufacturers referred
companies to us. And other vehicle manufacturers came asking us
about our technology," he wrote.
Jan-Olaf Willums, the president of Think, decided to place an
order, which Eberhard says will benefit Tesla in several ways.
Tesla will be able to ramp up to high-volume cell purchasing,
reducing costs. This will also increase the evolution of the cells,
perhaps reducing their weight. And the company will get an
additional revenue stream, allowing it to grow faster.
But Tesla will need even more money. Siry says venture capital,
given the company's prototype success and marketing buzz, is there
for the taking. "We're past the major risk," he says. "It's not
like we're a company with just an idea. We have a clear runway to
being a public company, which would probably need to occur as we
need access to larger and larger capital as we move forward with
our program."
Will Tesla perhaps sell out to one of the big boys when the time
comes? Siry says "everyone has their price" but that it's not in
the plan. "Our desire," he adds, "is to build an independent
brand."
To do that, Tesla will not rely on independent dealerships. It will
own all of its dealerships so it can control sales and service.
It's another way Tesla is following the path of Apple and not Ford
or GM. In his blog, Musk described the Tesla store: "The type of
place we are striving for combines the feel of an Apple store, a
Starbucks, and a good restaurant. I include the latter, because in
a good restaurant you can always see the chef working in the
kitchen. The chef has nothing to hide, and it is a pleasure to see
the staff at work preparing the meal."
Tesla plans to open stores in Los Angeles and the Bay Area by the
end of 2007 and in New York, Miami, and Chicago after that. Stores
in Seattle, Denver, Atlanta, Washington, D.C., and other cities
will follow based on customer demand.
But who will buy? Kevin Riddell, an analyst at J.D. Power and
Associates, says the Tesla Roadster is a major change from the
electric cars of the past, but it still has limitations. It has a
limited range, and while it has a fast recharge of as little as a
few hours, that still takes longer than pulling into a gas station
and filling up.
"I think from the electric vehicles we saw in the late '90s, the
technology is finally able to catch up with what people will expect
from a car in general, so it does make it more competitive, even
though it is more expensive than an internal combustion engine,"
Riddell says.
Riddell thinks instead there will be a big move toward hybrids. He
points out that there is currently no significant infrastructure in
place for an electric-only car. "Where do I go so I can plug in for
a few minutes and continue on my path outside of to and from home?"
he asks.